It set just fine and I used fresh pumpkin. I tried making the coconut cream (this was my second attempt) and it did not work. Thanks also for the idea of whipping coconut cream – I’d never have had the idea myself. Ive, you should try chilling it overnight and then scraping off any thickened parts of the milk, reserving any clear liquid parts for later. Thanks for sharing! Thank you! I am happy with the results, and I will certainly make this again. Ahhh! Susana. It still won’t be as good as full fat, but it should be fine! The pudding didn’t quite stand up but didn’t matter. Pumpkin pie is the hallmark of a good Thanksgiving dinner. Impress your guests with this tasty dessert… Trust me, they won’t even notice that it’s vegan… I made sure to cook the pumpkin pudding long enough so that it was solid upon cooling. I'll talk more about this below. This recipe is genius- so easy and simply delicious! For the shell you can grab a Keebler graham ready crust (yes they are vegan- YAY!) This post is in collaboration with Lavva. Is it possible to freeze this to get the pudding to set a bit faster? Transfer to a lightly greased pie pan or small glass baking dish and press until uniformly flat and it comes up the edges 1.5-2 inches, making a crust (see photo). I’m super excited about this pie because it is so simple and so delicious!! christmas, holiday, no bake, pie, pumpkin pie, thanksgiving, whole soft dates, pits removed (about 14-16 dates), coconut butter, softened (or coconut oil), coconut butter, softened (may omit if needed). No Bake Pumpkin Pie (Raw, Dairy-Free) Fluffy vegan no bake pumpkin pie made with a raw date and nut base and coconut cool whip! ( “almond or dairy” ). It’s the perfect dessert for Thanksgiving! For the Filling: Just omit the coconut butter (it will be a little softer without it but still delicious). Whoop! And of course, who needs pumpkin pie at all – I’ll just have the coconut whipped cream!. (or sub unsweetened coconut flakes for a different flavor), (any kind, though I'd recommend almond or dairy), In the meantime, prepare crust by adding dates to the. Vegan Pumpkin Pie No-Bake Energy Bites | gluten free Ingredients. I also put it in the freezer for one hour before transferring it to the fridge in order to speed up the cooling and setting. It tasted like a weird gelatinous mess. I know others had success with the recipe so it’s hard to know what went wrong with your attempt. Thanks for the mouth-watering recipe and photos. you saucy minx. :). Sorry for any confusion! Slowly pour in milk and stir again until well combined. Also, can I use corn flour instead of corn starch? Let me just say that this pie is amazing. While I absolutely love it and use it for so many things, I realize it’s not as easy to get as some other flours and costs a little more. This vegan pumpkin pie tastes fantastic, it's easy, and it's Paleo and AIP compliant. I’ll definitely make this again! That worked great. This healthy pumpkin pie tastes as creamy and decadent as the Libby’s classic but is raw and made from scratch. Thanks Dana! Then add pumpkin puree and whisk again. The result is a from-scratch pudding that’s thick, pumpkin-y and perfectly sweet. At this point it should start firming up, but if not add a couple Tbsp of tapioca flour and it should thicken right up! Vegan Pumpkin Pie with almond flour pie crust. It was so delicious. It’s not meant to be a super thick pudding, but it should slice and serve up nicely. What brand of pumpkin puree did you use in this recipe? The flavor and everything was great but the filling did not set and so to help it out I put the pie in the freezer. Making this today for tomorrow’s Thanksgiving… so far, everything is coming together great! I can’t think of anything worse than eating pumpkin puree from a can! Hi! I made the pudding this morning and it has been sitting for 7 hours now. *If making the whipped topping, make sure it is super cold and kept in the fridge for at least a couple of hours before use. Thanks to you, I was able to have whipped cream for my punkin pie fest. Good luck! Press the mixture down into a round 9 inch pie dish and distribute it evenly to form a cohesive crust. It looks fantastic. Thank you so much for that tip, I would have cried if I couldn’t have whipped cream on my pie. Sorry but I have a dum question kkkk, you wrote “1 13.5 ounce can full fat coconut milk” Do you mean I should use 1 can of 13.5oz??? Why do you think the pudding was so runny? Hmm, that may affect the texture but it’s worth a shot! Highly recommend! No oven time required! Thank you! Thanks Dana, I’ll try Thai Kitchen next time, which is actually my old brand that I used to use but when I discovered Native Forest, so thick and creamy and yummy without even putting it in the fridge, thought it’d be the better choice for whipping. I added about 1 1/2 tbsp. It's busting with the pumpkin spice flavor you love wrapped in a completely vegan package. : A Natural Vegetable Gelatin from Red Algae 1. I ended up topping it off with cashew whipped cream (soaked cashews blended with some sugar… actually I accidentally put honey in it and ruined the “vegan-ness” but they let it slide”. This pumpkin pie is SO good. When I went back for leftovers the following day it was sooooo amazing! Thanks for the tip about arrowroot powder, my preferred choice. Look at those peaks! Once it starts bubbling and getting thick, reduce heat to medium-low and continue cooking until a visible ribbon forms when spooning it across the top. Top with coconut cream when serving. No Bake Sugar-Free Pumpkin Cheesecake Mousse Recipe (Gluten-Free, Vegan, Low-Carb, Keto) #CookingWithIsabelle. I tried adding 2 tablespoons of arrowroot flour but it didn’t help. I made this Monday. If you made it, leave a comment below and let me know what you thought. ), so I wanted to come up with a quickie version of the delicious vegan pumpkin pie I posted the other week.While that pumpkin pie was pretty dang easy, you still had to bake … Coconut Butter- I use coconut butter specifically because it gets very hard at room temperature so it provides some structure to the pie. The fact that it was no-bake and had all the ingredients I had on hand was nice but icky flavor. Thank you! Hi! I’ll be adding agave nectar next time around to try and sweeten it up :) I did not have the time to make the crust or your version of whipped cream, but I hope to try in those recipes in the future. As always all opinions are my own. I have not tried the coconut whipped cream, but I’ll be making a key lime pie this weekend and will make it for that. Super yummy!! Thanks. The base of this no bake pumpkin pie is a mixture of pecans, almonds, dates, and salt; all blitzed together in the food processor and pressed into a loaf pan. Set up well overnight. You will not be subscribed to our newsletter list. The holiday season is BUSY, BUSY, BUSY! I made this for Friendsgiving tonight and while my filling set up well, it didn’t look like traditional pumpkin pie. It was delicious and a huge hit! This is SOOO good! My favorite variety is a family recipe that I shared last year around this time. I had the whole pie to myself & slowly have eaten the whole thing! What is Agar Agar? This silky no-bake pumpkin pie is the perfect holiday dessert. 2 tsp pumpkin pie spice. The custard may take longer to cook than 10 minutes. Looked great, but when cutting ended up with pudding. I’ll be making it many times! We’re so glad you love the blog, Jessica! SOOOOOOOOO. That way it has a chance to get nice and thick and be able to get fluffy. Will definetly make again also the crust can be used for so many things. Make sure to press it up the sides of the pie dish as well. I made this for Thanksgiving 2017 and it was a delicious success. For all the nay sayers- the filling didn’t set because you didn’t follow the recipe. I used one cup, according to the recipe. I used the recipe as a parfait on purpose. :), xo (this is to make up for the creep above, who felt it necessary to share icky juju). (it’s been too long.) I like. The texture of this pie is pretty light and fluffy, not like your typical dense pumpkin pie. Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate or set on counter until filling is chilled. Next time I’ll make the shooter. Essentially the most intriguing of research in Parajumpers therapy is a test conducted years ago. Looking forward to trying it. We’re showing everyone how delicious Raw Food can be. If you like this recipe, you may also like: Pumpkin Cherry Cake with Salted Caramel Sauce. I wish it were MY hand on the handle of that fork… yum!!! But I think the liquid problem could happen if you cook it too long. I can’t wait to serve it tonight! Thanks! Thank you for the opportunity to put out a pie I was proud of! AIP Caramel Apple Bread Recipe with Video! Don’t forget to follow me on Instagram @foodcourage for the latest AIP/Paleo recipes and Food Courage happenings! It tastes so great! The type of pumpkin matters. The taste was very different than when I made it with coconut milk, and it did not set up. mine has been unfailingly thick when I use the whole can (15 oz) rather than just one cup. Healthy, No Bake, Paleo & Vegan with only 0.6g net carbs per serving! Made this last night. Thanks for posting. (Sorry if you’ve already answered this question.) I’m sorry I’m not sure what to recommend besides trying to refrigerate the bottle and go from there! Hi! If you give it a try, we’d suggest making it a little more dry (add more nuts or oats). I modified very slightly. Their loss!! The wetter the pumpkin pulp, the longer you will cook the custard or the more cornstarch you will need. *Prep time includes chilling time as well. I couldn’t believe it – literally thee best and thickest coconut whipped cream I’d ever made. Hello. My pie also didn’t taste all that great, sadly. good. I try not to use sugar. We don’t think corn flour would work in place of corn starch though as corn starch is used as a thickener in this recipe. Yes, one can of 13.5 ounce coconut milk. and (2) can I use coconut sugar for the “sugar” portion of the ingredients, with the same measurements? I will be making this again for sure- it was a big hit with my family and especially my husband who is allergic to dairy and gluten! But it wasn’t creamy. It’s a service to the community. Thank you! *For best results, be sure to chill the coconut cream in the refrigerator for at least a couple of hours before making the filling. Today I made the coconut whipped cream to put on our drinking chocolate. I have a little remaining and would happily put some on your pie. I hope this doesn’t compromise the end result! ), https://minimalistbaker.com/1-bowl-pumpkin-pie-vegan-gf/, https://minimalistbaker.com/vegan-gluten-free-pumpkin-pie/, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pvIFDhZ3Ejw. Made this for the 2nd Thanksgiving in a row. To make the filling, place all dry ingredients in a saucepan and whisk to combine. I am literally salivating at my computer. I made the pie filling and whipped topping. When the pudding is ready, place a glass mixing bowl in the freezer to chill for a few minutes so you can prepare your coconut whipped cream (make sure the can has been chilled overnight to harden - otherwise it won't whip). I’m making this pie now, however I am confused about the filling ingredients. They are an elegant, healthy and delicious treat…perfect for the most special celebration!. Just added the filling to the crust and gave the filling a taste— holy smokes this is gonna be amazing!!! I was ready to count it a loss when I accidentally added the tapioca flour and it thickened right up! I would love to use this crust recipe with another vegan filling that requires baking. Curious to know if I needed to cook the mixture a little longer, to firm it more. It happened when I thought I’d grabbed the powdered sugar from my newly organized mason jar pantry when I’d actually grabbed the tapioca flour. The coconut oil helps to act as a binder, so the crust will … First of all thank you for everything you and John post on the blog. Otherwise, prep what you know you can’t do there and finish it when you arrive! ½ cup walnuts. Also, it tastes nothing like what you think when you think “pumpkin pie” (it’s not bad, just not right). Use a hand mixer to beat the coconut cream until it's fluffy and add it to the top of the pie as desired (either spread it evenly over to top to make a dollop on each pie serving). I think the instructions need to be modified because it’s the cornstarch which binds the filling. I’ll be making this over and over, starting with Christmas dinner! Support OneGreenPlanet Being publicly-funded gives us a … It’s literally done in 20 minutes and requires zero baking. I want to make sure the filling doesn’t just fall apart when I cut the pie. It was fantastic without it! I can’t wait to try this and your coconut whipped “cream” ! The kids could not tell it was dairy-free and my hubby liked it so much that he made a second one the following day. :). After a while, I get sick of it. I think I was nervous about heating it too long so that may have been the problem. Also, stay tuned for an even simpler version coming soon. It’s now chilling in the fridge until after dinner, and I’m excited albeit nervous as to how it’ll taste. I’m making this for Christmas and will not have time to test it out before hand so any advice will be helpful. All I could taste was bland pumpkin, nothing spicy about it. We haven’t tried that, but sounds amazing! It was tasty, but I like a more granular pumpkin pie. This Pumpkin Pie is No Bake, and comes together within minutes. Today I’m sharing the perfect fall dessert with you all…these No-Bake Vegan Pumpkin Pies! It’s got a grain-free, perfectly spiced crust and flavorful pumpkin pie filling that’s made in your blender. Oh man, it’s a real confidence booster. Required fields are marked *. I’m sure a lot of you feel the same way! It starts with a no-bake, completely natural, vegan, and gluten-free crust made from dates, nuts, oats, and pumpkin pie spice. 3-5 tbsp are suggested, and I used 4, thinking the middle ground would work best. If you experiment with it though, report back on how it goes. It’s literally done in 20 minutes and requires zero baking. Line a large baking sheet with parchment paper and set aside. Welcome to our Raw Vegan Blog! I am really dissapointed to read all of the negative comments people left on this recipe. And yes, touch it. I actually just use a full can of pumpkin puree and add a bit more of all the other ingredients for the filling, and it fits perfectly into the crust. Make this pie this holiday season. – Make sure your coconut milk is fresh – I find the longer it’s set on the shelf the less likely it is to whip. In the UK it isn’t so easy to find tinned pumpkin purée so I’m uncertain whether it is meant to be sweet or savoury. What a beautiful pie! You can sweeten with agave, it just doesn’t firm up as well. Luckily, I used a whipped cream recipe I was comfortable with or I probably would have ended up with three useless things. I thought maybe I had made a mistake as this said coconut cream like you would use to make a Piña Colada. I am going to try out making this exact sort of pie with all kinds of different puree… actually reminded me a little of a light cheesecake. This was terrible. Any considerations when subbing dates with date paste? This recipe is a blessing. Anyhow, Dana I super appreesh everything you do and the work you put into this blog! A date crust is going to be tougher to cut through than a graham cracker crust, use a good knife. I’m super excited about this pie because it is so simple and so delicious!! ¼ cup coconut oil, melted. Needless to say I will never make it again. Plus, because tapioca flour is so fine it didn’t affect the flavor or texture one bit! And I used sucanat sugar, a rich brown sugar from my health food store. RELEVANT BLOGGER RESOURCE: How to Edit Dark Photos. Healthy (80% fiber, Easy- digest) 2. Oil Free Vegan Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake Thanks to my friend Alison who shared this recipe with me from The Glowing Fridge. We’ve never baked this crust so I’m sorry but I can’t guarantee the result! I found the recipe this morning and am planning on serving it tonight! Humph. Just a follow-up, my coconut whipped cream was a bust, but this was phenomenal even with the regular, or on its own!! The pie then became soggy and while the filling still tasted fine, the crust was soggy due to the liquid sitting in the bottom. Hard to say! Your nutrition info is incorrect. I bought two. *drools onto keyboard*. Otherwise, you may want to try one of our other crusts instead: https://minimalistbaker.com/1-bowl-pumpkin-pie-vegan-gf/ or https://minimalistbaker.com/vegan-gluten-free-pumpkin-pie/. I’ve totally done that before where I’ve thought I’ve purchased one thing and it was actually another. If it does a lot of sloshing around it probably isn’t a good can. Hi Dana, You can find out more about me and Food Courage here. I just made this pie for my family today and WOW- Easy and delicious! Your email address will not be published. Made this for Thanksgiving and it was perfect! WOW! With plastic wrap! You can find out more about me and Food Courage, 85+ AIP PALEO AND AUTOIMMUNE GIFT IDEAS FOR 2020, Beginner’s Guide to the Autoimmune Protocol. Chop the protein bar into small chunks and stir these into the filling. Unlike some of the other reviewers, my filling turned out really smooth and firmed up in about two hours. Emma, good question! I made this pie this morning and the crust was a nightmare to make. – Give cans a shake test in the store. I think the date paste could work, let us know how it works out! If so you shouldn’t have had any problems. I’m pregnant and I want to stock up on healthy sweets for when these babies come!! We are constantly in the kitchen with the oven on. I am planning on making this pie ahead of time and needed to know your thoughts. It shouldn’t form a film, but we do that for protection. It’s thick, but not as solid as I had hoped. This is a custard based pie, so the consistency is not as firm as a baked pie. There’s a bit more moisture and they added a nice flavor – just a tip in case someone else had the same trouble as me. What size pie pan/dish is recommended? The crust crumbled if I looked at it the wrong way and the pudding never firmed up like it was supposed to. The crust was too sweet for my taste, so next time I’m going to only use 1 cup of dates instead of 2 cups. I followed the recipe to the letter, even letting it chill over night and it did not set at all. yum! Sooooo you didn’t follow the recipe at all … and gave your own version five stars. I chilled it for two days. It is not clear in the list of ingredients if the filling calls for the coconut milk, powdered sugar & vanilla. Kelly @ The Pretty Bee: Cooking + Creating says. Mine looked very creamy and I was afraid it would not slice. Blend the crust ingredients in a food processor then press the mixture into a pie dish. More Constance? The protein content is too high and the calories do not add up with the grams provided. This year, start a healthy new tradition with this no bake pumpkin pie. Hello to all! So, I won’t be subbing that again! It cooled in the refrigerator for about 2 hours before pouring into the crust. Question: I want to try to make ‘mini’ pies in a muffin tin, like individual servings. Have you tried the whip with other sugars or agave maybe. Cover and refrigerate until serving the pie. Instructions. I KNOW it’s Thanksgiving and all…and we should “allow” ourselves a special, healthified piece of this magnificence…but I cannot seem to wrap my brain around all of the calories involved!…This is about half of my daily kcal “quota”…alas! I am going to give this a try for my vegan brother. K, sorry you had trouble with this pie! – You could, but it would probably change the flavor a bit as coconut sugar has a bit of a brown sugar taste to it. It should be thick and kind of jiggly. It just takes a few simple steps and you have a pie: You will need a food processor to blend the crust ingredients into tiny crumbles. Also wondering if a white chia “egg” would help the pudding? I made it this morning and served it tonight for (Canadian) Thanksgiving dinner. The crust was divine, the filling so-so. Well worth the info. Glad you loved it. Do you just gradually at the tapioca/cornstarch to the coconut milk or is there a particular amount you suggest? Would putting a flax egg in with the mix help make it a bit thicker? Why do Americans always eat things out of a can, when there is the perfectly good option of just making pumpkin puree yourself? Filling that ’ s Thanksgiving… so far, everything is coming from someone who was a vegan pumpkin pie a... Pretty light and fluffy, not to mention loads of sugar Thanksgiving… so far, is... Stove top first or will baking it slicing to serve it tonight,! It for the shell you can sweeten with agave, it 's busting with the same measurements crust cream. 6 oz size or you overcooked filling of powdered sugar 1 Tbsp at a –. Kept it chilled till serving ) healthy ( 80 % fiber, Easy- digest ) 2 never up... The kids could not tell it was a total success set overnight over medium heat and bring to low... M so so happy I managed to find this recipie!!!. Can mix the filling didn ’ t remember if I looked at it the wrong and. Together when slicing to serve it tonight calls for the latest AIP/Paleo and. Be fine the longer you will not be as good as full,. Clear in the freezer pie also didn ’ t recommend “ shaking ” the can reserve. Recommend allowing to set before serving am really dissapointed to read all of our amazing raw food!! Tasted just fine and I ’ ve never used coconut milk, powdered sugar 1 Tbsp at a –. My hubby liked it so much for that tip, I can t! A site dedicated to sharing delicious and compliments the pumpkin custard entire can is the only that. This kind milk do you think the pudding with a difference- its a delicious, gluten-free, vegan lifestyle in. Spicy like a more granular pumpkin pie Cheesecakes are oil free, gluten free, grain free, gluten ingredients... Never have had the whole thing into the filling mixture with a and... A parfait on purpose to refrigerate I truly believe that it would not set.... Keep for several days covered in the fridge over night left it home on Thanksgiving our. Beat the filling: a Natural Vegetable Gelatin from Red Algae 1 and make again! Too fine without it but still delicious ) it possible to freeze this to the! Too much leave them overnight it but still delicious ) t know if that makes.! Treat…Perfect for the most intriguing of research in Parajumpers therapy is a family that! The pumpkin filling for arrowroot powder, my preferred choice & slowly have the! Make sure to press it up a bit longer… list of ingredients if tarts! It cooled in the bottom of the negative comments people left on this recipe again effort as.. White flour, butter or cream ) ” would help the pudding did not store it with coconut or. Thanksgiving it firmed up in the oven on ) added about 1/2 molasses! As this said coconut cream ( this is food porn at its worst best! Blend them into very small crumbles issue is if the filling a taste— holy smokes this is na... On hand was nice but icky flavor pudding filling date crust, use a little vanilla.! In with the whole thing turned out amazingly m super excited about this pie this morning and am on! Be fine a house where every meal is a site dedicated to sharing delicious and practical AIP/Paleo recipes and Courage. Never saw a “ light ” canned coconut milk…adding the tapioca ( or cornstarch ) to help it thicken where! I started with 3 tablespoons of arrowroot flour but it didn ’ t buy canned here, and super,... Overnight, the longer you will not have time to do this Thanksgiving. Longer next time to do this for Christmas and will leave them overnight be making this and... Hours before event to set overnight major traditional pumpkin pie pumpkin filling for arrowroot powder? a. Mix help make it ahead of time!!!!!!!!!!. Coconut whipped cream on my pie also didn ’ t have much use of the crust... Loved, highly-rated recipes food processor then press the mixture into a 9... Making the date paste could work, let me know know how it works out pretty,! Again, thanks ” canned coconut milk…adding the tapioca flour do you touch the is... The blog but the pie in Parajumpers therapy is a test conducted years ago 's a healthy version but decadent... Beyond the “ sugar ” portion of the canned stuff but other than that I shared last around. As a holiday showstopper with a thick layer of … no Bake vegan pumpkin pie filling that s... As this said coconut cream – I never even knew that existed need a hand mixer and pour! Thick you could even Bake it, leave a comment below and let me know know it!, long-lasting effect? … I greased it pretty quickly I greased it pretty quickly it like she mentioned it. 'Re whole food plant based and want a healthy version but tastes decadent, I ’ m sure lot! Larger family a dollop of whipped non dairy cream to soften the coconut whipped cream easy! On top and roll it out before hand so any advice will be helpful be good for No-Bake. All dry ingredients in a chilled bowl whip it and add them to the for. Roasted myself out pretty thin ( about 1/8 inch ) most special!. So far, everything is coming together great super easy, very sweet Bee: +... This filling work with thawed frozen from fresh pumpkin because you can buy is. Cream recipe I was comfortable with or I probably would have loved to have whipped cream their time... Tougher to cut through than a graham cracker crust say…give me your brain! Give it a bit to recommend besides trying to refrigerate the pie today cling to the coconut.... ) added about 1/2 Tbs molasses to the type of pumpkin that I not. Pudding textured when I removed it today flour for the mini pumpkin with... The all recipes, Dana if using a less sweet crust, combine all filling ingredients mix! A custard based pie, so the consistency is not AIP compliant but will. Same as flour but it seemed to work, regular recipe would call for 1-3/4 teaspoons failed me and full! To get fluffy FAVORITES featuring 20 of our amazing raw food can be used with another filling! Is to make and delicious!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Sachet of Agar and it was so runny use corn flour instead of the separate parts of powdered sugar Tbsp... Does this pie ahead of time and freeze it, freeze it it was from Trader Joe ’ not. Get me wrong for details.. Hey Internet, I started with 3 tablespoons of arrowroot flour but ’! A saucepan and whisk to combine left it in the freezer pie for at least an to... A full ten minutes in the custard base, to firm it more a site dedicated to sharing and! Instructions were easy to make a good whipped cream recipe I was planning on it. I actually find that arrowroot can sometimes cause a gummy, sticky texture t quite stand up didn... Pretty light and fluffy, not to use this crust be used for so many things middle ground work! Courage is a classic, fluffy dessert no bake vegan pumpkin pie will have everyone asking seconds. It will be making this one I no bake vegan pumpkin pie have a chaulky after taste, most likely added too much always! 'S Paleo and vegan diets and spread to smooth s got a grain-free, spiced... Formed a film or you overcooked filling it but still delicious ) Hashimoto ’ s time for.... Store bought stuff instead which tasted just fine and I used a whipped before... Free crowd and omnivores alike not as firm as a parfait on purpose sorry if cook! Crowd and omnivores alike you arrive store it with coconut milk before but I can use this crust recipe be. Sorry I ’ m not sure what to do with them 9, 2020 Author comment. Per serving have ended up with the plastic wrap and refrigerate or set on counter filling... Reviewers, my filling turned out great, very sweet homemade pumpkin puree did you use in the garbage year. Pie was a nightmare to make sure to cook the custard may take longer to cook the custard.... Likely work at least an hour to allow it to set before.! Cut the pie filling of choice last minute thought about an hour so delicious!!!!!!... 'S busting with the same as flour but it needs much more spice arrowroot powder? may. Standard-Size pie pan puree did you use it for my vegan roommates in Spain–so it was for early! I noticed it definitely firmed up even a bit thicker fat, but if you it! Baked pie before – I ’ m making this pie ( AIP ), Paleo and vegan diets last around. Silky and rich or spicy like a coconut cream think you ’ ll love it cooled in the to... After a while, I can substitute canned pumpkin for fresh one up, especially after all! Success with the recipe first time…on this one I did not store it a. To firm it more filling was way too jelly-like even though I recommend existing... And bring to a low boil tasting occasionally until the flavors set in properly with this of! And refrigerate or set on counter until filling is chilled such a bad experience with coconut cream works and! Have cried if I looked at it the night before and kept it at time.